Patent Assist

Can Artificial Intelligence replace Patent Agents?

Written by Team PatentAssist

Revolutionized by the emergence of powerful language models (Chat GPT, Lambda, LLama, etc.), individuals entrenched within the corporate and academic hierarchy have been compelled to reevaluate their perspectives on artificial intelligence. Tailoring a language model to a specific task or domain enhances its performance by allowing it to harness the specialized vocabulary, context, and intricacies relevant to that area.

A sense of bewilderment now pervades as even the most technically adept individuals contemplate the unsettling possibility of their roles being supplanted. This rapid shift has prompted a fundamental query: Can AI truly supersede their expertise and contributions?

Advantages of patent agent’s expertise

In the realm of patent drafting, a domain long reliant on meticulous and technical human expertise, the landscape is about to go under an extraordinary metamorphosis. The main idea here is that the patent agent needs to really understand the technical details of the invention. This helps them create a Complete Specifications of the invention and corresponding Claims from the inventors' invention disclosure. Doing this requires some training over technical and legal language to patent all the relevant details from the invention disclosure. The key is to really understand what sets the invention apart and makes it unique. The most crucial part is to describe everything in a way that's just right with the tipping scale – between generality and specificity. This balance gives the inventor an edge over their competition and keep their innovation away from infringement. This understanding is really important for the whole drafting process which is difficult for Artificial intelligence to imitate.

Core competencies for the Large Language Models

Large language models, such as ChatGPT and others, are advanced AI systems designed to comprehend and generate human-like text. These models are trained on massive datasets containing labelled diverse conversational text from the internet, allowing them to learn the complexities of language and context. Their advantages stem from their ability to perform a wide range of natural language processing tasks, including Patent drafting.

Utilization of Patent Databases

One of their remarkable strengths is their capacity to learn from a vast array of existing patents and technical literature. These models can sift through extensive databases of patent documents, scientific papers, and other relevant sources to develop an in-depth understanding of different technologies and their associated legal terminologies in Patent claims.

Precise Techno-Legal Language

Large language models excel in generating coherent and precise language, which is crucial in patent drafting to clearly define the scope of an invention. They can craft Background, Summary, Detailed descriptions of the invention, its components, and its functionalities. Moreover, these models can create claims – the legally significant part of a patent – that accurately delineate the protected aspects of the invention, also

Speed and efficiency: First Draft

LLMs can rapidly process and analyze large volumes of text. By employing LLMs to review invention disclosures, the patent drafting process can be initiated quickly. This acceleration is particularly valuable in today's fast-paced business environment, where getting to the patent application stage promptly can provide a competitive edge. LLMs possess the capability to comprehend complex technical jargon and nuances present in invention disclosures. Their broad knowledge base allows them to interpret the invention's technical details accurately

Collaborative environment

The basic draft produced by the LLM serves as a foundation for collaboration between the patent agent and the inventors. The agent can build upon the initial draft, refining it with their legal expertise and incorporating specific details provided by the inventors. This helps to maintain a consistent style and terminology throughout the initial draft which ensures that the patent application follows a standardized format, reducing the likelihood of errors or inconsistencies that can arise from manual drafting. Further, the patent agent can collaboratively work with the AI for idea exploration for the Complete specification and Claims, constantly learn and improve along the way.

Limitations of state-of-the-art LLMs in patent drafting

While the core competency of LLMs offers substantial advantages in patent drafting, certain limitations must be acknowledged.

  1. These include the need for accurate prompting to guide the model effectively within the technolegal framework. For instance, prompting the model towards the realm of biochemistry engineering or steering it towards electrical and electronics technolegal terminology. Advanced training techniques are essential to ensure the model's proficiency across various domains required for processing potential invention disclosures.
  2. Precisely aligning segments of information from the invention disclosure to the corresponding sections of the patent draft holds paramount importance. Our experience underscores the model's inadequacy in inherently learning this intricate mapping from extensive data alone, thus necessitating supervised labeling.
  3. Consequently, utilizing the dataset directly to train a Draft generation engine empowered by LLMs is not feasible. Instead, a meticulously curated collection of input and output sets, encompassing the entire process from invention disclosure to Draft generation and claim formulation, is indispensable for elevating the quality of model performance.
  4. The transition from traditional Inventor-patent agent communication to the dynamic Inventor-artificial intelligence collaboration demands a structured approach. This can be facilitated through precisely formatted invention disclosures that optimize the automation process and foster a seamless adaptation of communication.

Question is not ‘Can AI replace patent agent?’ but ‘How can AI empower patent agents?’

The established conventional approach is currently facing remarkable upheaval due to the advancement of AI-powered systems, which are progressively showcasing their adeptness in navigating the intricacies of this intricate domain. However, owing to the limitations elucidated, we find ourselves at least a decade, if not multiple decades, away from achieving complete automation of draft generation and prior art search.

Nonetheless, the question of adaptation assumes significant prominence. It emerges not merely as a choice but as an imperative, particularly for those aspiring to retain their forefront position in the realm of innovation. This is underscored by the fact that individuals incorporating AI enhancement into their draft automation processes will undoubtedly harness these capabilities to augment their overall throughput.

The crux of the matter lies in harnessing the prowess of AI-augmented patent drafting tools. Large language models have indeed shown a significant trend of advancement in recent years. These models, which are built on deep learning techniques, have grown in size and number of parameters (as shown in the above figure). These cutting-edge solutions wield the potential to exponentially amplify productivity, streamline workflows, and elevate the quality of output. The imminent fusion of AI and human ingenuity is undeniable, poised to envelop even those who resist its arrival. This convergence mirrors the pattern observed in previous technological revolutions. The amalgamation of human ingenuity with AI acumen has paved the way for an evolution in patent drafting that is nothing short of revolutionary.

← Back to Blog