Skip to content

European Patent Convention · Patentability

Article 56 EPC: Inventive step

Annotated by , Co-founder and CEO, PatentAssist.ai
Updated

Text of Article 56 EPC

An invention shall be considered as involving an inventive step if, having regard to the state of the art, it is not obvious to a person skilled in the art. If the state of the art also includes documents within the meaning of Article 54, paragraph 3, these documents shall not be considered in deciding whether there has been an inventive step.

Article 56 EPC, excerpt. Full official text on epo.org

In plain English

Article 56 asks one question: would the claimed invention have been obvious to a person skilled in the art, given the state of the art? Novelty under Article 54 comes first; a claim that is not new never reaches Article 56.

The skilled person is a practitioner in the relevant field with average knowledge and ability, who knows the common general knowledge and has access to everything in the state of the art, in particular the documents in the search report, and can do routine work and experimentation. If the problem points to another field, the specialist in that field is the skilled person (Guidelines G-VII, 3).

The second sentence matters in practice. Earlier European applications published after your filing date (Article 54(3) documents) count against novelty only. They can never be used against inventive step.

To keep the assessment objective, the EPO uses the problem-solution approach: determine the closest prior art, establish the objective technical problem from the technical effects the distinguishing features provide over it, and then ask whether the claimed solution would have been obvious to the skilled person starting from that prior art and problem (Guidelines G-VII, 5).

The last step is the could-would test. The question is not whether the skilled person could have arrived at the invention, but whether the prior art as a whole would have prompted them to do so in the expectation of some improvement or advantage (Guidelines G-VII, 5.3, citing T 2/83).

For claims that mix technical and non-technical features, such as computer-implemented business methods, only the features that contribute to the technical character count towards inventive step; a non-technical aim can appear in the problem as a given constraint (T 641/00, Guidelines G-VII, 5.4).

Key decisions

  • T 2/83 (Simethicone Tablet) : Cited in the Guidelines (G-VII, 5.3) for the could-would test: what matters is whether the skilled person would have modified the prior art in the expectation of an improvement or advantage, not merely whether they could have.
  • T 641/00 (Two identities/COMVIK) : For a mix of technical and non-technical features, inventive step is assessed on the features that contribute to technical character; a non-technical aim may appear in the problem as a constraint.
  • G 2/21 (Plausibility) : An applicant may rely on a technical effect for inventive step if the skilled person, from the application as filed, would derive it as encompassed by the technical teaching and embodied by the original invention.

Common objections

Obvious over D1 combined with D2

The most common objection. Check whether the examiner chose the right closest prior art, whether the objective problem is framed without hindsight, and whether anything in D2 would really have prompted the combination rather than merely allowed it.

No technical effect for the distinguishing feature

If a feature brings no technical effect over the closest prior art, the problem becomes finding an alternative, and arbitrary choices are usually obvious. The effect has to be derivable from the application as filed (G 2/21).

Non-technical features ignored

Typical for software and business-method claims under the COMVIK approach. The answer is to show how the feature interacts with the technical features to produce a technical effect.

Drafting and prosecution tips

  • Describe the technical effect of each important feature in the application as filed; you cannot rely on an effect the skilled person could not derive from it.
  • Answer an inventive step objection in the problem-solution format, stage by stage. Examiners and Boards expect it.
  • Keep fallback features with their own technical effects in the dependent claims and description.

Related provisions

In the Guidelines for Examination (2026)

PatentAssist guides

All annotated EPC provisions

EPC excerpts are quoted from the European Patent Convention, 17th edition, as amended and published by the European Patent Office. Practice notes follow the Guidelines for Examination in the EPO (April 2026) and the Boards of Appeal decisions cited. Fees are those in force from 1 April 2026. This is general information, not legal advice: check the official text and confirm deadlines with a European patent attorney.